Snow Melting System Controls

Overview

Control systems determine the operational efficiency and energy consumption of snow melting installations. Proper control design balances the competing objectives of reliable snow removal, minimal energy waste, and protection against false starts during non-snow precipitation events. The control strategy directly affects the annual operating cost, which often exceeds the initial capital investment over the system lifetime.

Snow melting controls must address three fundamental challenges: detecting the onset of snowfall before significant accumulation occurs, managing slab thermal mass during warmup, and preventing unnecessary operation during rain or brief snow flurries. Modern systems employ automatic controls that eliminate the need for manual intervention while optimizing energy consumption.

Sensor Technologies

Pavement-Mounted Sensors

Pavement sensors install flush with the heated surface and provide direct measurement of surface conditions. These devices integrate multiple sensing elements in a single assembly to detect precipitation, snow accumulation, and pavement temperature.

Sensing elements include:

• Moisture detection grids - Measure electrical conductivity between exposed electrodes to detect water presence
• RTD or thermistor temperature sensors - Monitor pavement surface temperature with ±1°F accuracy
• Precipitation rate sensors - Differentiate between light moisture and active precipitation
• Snow depth grids - Detect snow accumulation through capacitive or conductive sensing

Pavement sensors require embedding during construction or cutting into existing slabs. The sensor face must be positioned flush with the finished surface to ensure accurate snow detection. Installation depth varies from 1/4 inch to 1/2 inch below the final surface depending on manufacturer specifications.

Advantages:

• Direct measurement of actual surface conditions
• Accurate temperature sensing at the critical interface
• Reliable snow vs. rain discrimination
• No wind or angle effects

Limitations:

• Potential damage from snow removal equipment
• Requires slab penetration
• Sensor location fixed permanently
• Limited coverage area (typically 4-6 inch diameter)

Aerial-Mounted Sensors

Aerial sensors mount above the protected area on poles, walls, or building overhangs. These devices detect falling precipitation through optical, infrared, or heated grid technologies without contact with the pavement surface.

Detection methods:

1. Infrared precipitation sensors - Detect moisture using infrared beam interruption when water droplets pass through the sensing volume
2. Heated grid sensors - Monitor power required to maintain a small heated element at setpoint; increased power indicates precipitation
3. Optical sensors - Detect precipitation particles through light scattering or imaging techniques

Aerial sensors pair with a separate pavement temperature sensor (typically RTD embedded in the slab edge) to provide surface temperature data. The control logic combines precipitation detection with temperature measurement to determine system activation.

Advantages:

• Protected from mechanical damage
• Easier access for maintenance
• Can monitor larger areas
• Replaceable without pavement damage

Limitations:

• Wind effects may cause false triggers
• Mounting angle affects performance
• Indirect measurement of surface conditions
• Requires separate temperature sensor

Control Strategies

Automatic Control Modes

Mode 1: Automatic Snow Detection

The system activates when the sensor detects precipitation AND pavement temperature falls below a setpoint (typically 34-38°F). This mode provides hands-off operation for the entire season.

Control logic:

IF (Precipitation Detected = YES) AND (Pavement Temp < Setpoint)
THEN Activate System

This strategy prevents operation during rain events above freezing but responds immediately when snow begins falling on cold pavement.

Mode 2: Automatic with Manual Override

Combines automatic operation with manual start capability. Operators can force system activation before anticipated storms or disable the system during extended warm periods. The manual override typically includes a timeout (24-72 hours) to prevent indefinite operation.

Mode 3: Temperature-Only Preheating

Some installations use temperature-only activation (without precipitation sensing) to maintain pavement above freezing throughout winter. This “idling” strategy eliminates slab warmup delay but consumes substantial energy during clear cold weather.

Applicable only for critical areas requiring immediate snow-free conditions such as hospital emergency entrances or airport equipment ramps.

Advanced Control Features

Slab Warmup Anticipation

Controllers calculate required lead time based on slab thermal mass, fluid temperature, and heat flux capacity. The system pre-starts before precipitation begins using weather forecast data or by detecting declining pavement temperatures with high humidity (indicating approaching storm systems).

Warmup time calculation:

t_warmup = (m × c × ΔT) / Q_available

Where:

• t_warmup = Required warmup time (hours)
• m = Slab thermal mass (lb)
• c = Concrete specific heat (0.22 BTU/lb·°F)
• ΔT = Temperature rise required (°F)
• Q_available = Available heat flux (BTU/hr)

Multi-Zone Control

Large installations divide into zones with independent control. Zones may activate based on individual sensor inputs or staged sequencing to limit peak power demand. Priority zones (entries, ramps) receive preferential activation over secondary areas (general parking).

Time Delay Settings

Controllers incorporate multiple delay timers:

The after-run delay proves critical for system effectiveness. Premature shutdown leaves residual moisture that refreezes after system deactivation. ASHRAE recommends minimum 30-minute after-run following precipitation cessation.

Energy Management

Proper control strategy reduces annual energy consumption by 30-60% compared to manual operation or continuous idling modes. The largest savings derive from:

1. Eliminating false starts - Moisture discrimination prevents operation during rain above freezing
2. Minimizing after-run - Sensors detect dry pavement to limit unnecessary operation
3. Zoning and staging - Activate only required areas with sequenced startup
4. Setpoint optimization - Higher activation temperatures (36-38°F vs 32°F) reduce runtime for marginal events

Weather prediction integration enables pre-warming high-thermal-mass slabs before snow arrival while preventing activation for storms that miss the location. Internet-connected controllers access forecast data automatically and adjust operation accordingly.

The annual operating cost calculation must account for standby losses, slab warmup energy, active snow melting load, and after-run consumption. Proper sensor placement and control tuning optimize the balance between reliable snow removal and energy conservation.

Design Considerations

Control system design requires coordination with mechanical system capacity. The controller must receive input signals matching the sensor types and output signals compatible with the heating plant controls (boiler firing, pump activation, valve operation).

Essential design elements:

• Redundant sensors for critical applications
• Weather-resistant enclosures (NEMA 4X minimum)
• Backup power for control systems during outages
• Data logging capability for performance verification
• Integration with building automation systems
• Alarm outputs for sensor failures

Proper commissioning includes verification of sensor calibration, control logic timing, and system response to simulated conditions. Document all setpoints, time delays, and operational parameters for future reference and seasonal adjustment.

ASHRAE Handbook - HVAC Applications Chapter 51 provides detailed guidance on control system selection, sensor placement, and operational strategies for various snow melting applications.

Sections