Fire and EMS Station HVAC Systems

Design Overview

Fire and EMS stations present unique HVAC challenges due to the combination of large apparatus bays with frequent door openings, diesel exhaust contamination risks, continuously occupied living quarters, and stringent indoor air quality requirements. The design must maintain thermal comfort for personnel during extended shifts while preventing exhaust migration into occupied spaces and managing significant infiltration loads from bay door operations.

The fundamental design challenge arises from three distinct functional zones operating under different thermal and ventilation requirements: high-bay apparatus areas with vehicle exhaust, administrative and training spaces following commercial building standards, and residential-style living quarters requiring continuous comfort and privacy.

Apparatus Bay Heating

Heating System Selection

Apparatus bays demand heating systems capable of rapid temperature recovery following frequent door openings while providing even temperature distribution across large floor areas. The thermal mass of fire apparatus and concrete floors creates substantial heating loads beyond standard infiltration calculations.

Radiant Floor Heating: Provides optimal comfort and efficiency for apparatus bays:

• Embedded hydronic tubing in concrete slab (typically 6-inch spacing)
• Supply water temperature 110-130°F for moderate climates, 130-150°F for cold climates
• Heat output 20-30 BTU/hr·ft² at design conditions
• Prevents ice and snow accumulation beneath vehicles
• Eliminates air stratification and drafts common with overhead systems

Design considerations:

• Slab insulation required beneath tubing (minimum R-10 perimeter, R-5 under slab)
• Zone control for different bay areas and apparatus sizes
• Warm-up time 4-8 hours from cold start requires continuous operation or overnight setback limitations
• Thermal response time prohibits deep setback strategies

Unit Heaters: Alternative or supplementary heating approach:

• Gas-fired or hydronic unit heaters mounted 12-16 feet above floor
• Capacity 100,000-300,000 BTU/hr per unit typical
• Horizontal discharge with destratification fans improves distribution
• Fast response allows greater temperature setback when bay unoccupied

Sizing Methodology: Apparatus bay heating loads include standard components plus bay-specific factors:

Standard heat loss calculation: Q_total = Q_envelope + Q_infiltration + Q_slab + Q_makeup

Where:

• Q_envelope: Transmission through walls, roof, doors (calculate per ASHRAE methods)
• Q_infiltration: Air leakage through building envelope
• Q_slab: Edge and perimeter losses (if radiant floor not installed)
• Q_makeup: Ventilation air heating if provided

Bay door infiltration correction: Standard infiltration calculations significantly underestimate bay door air leakage:

Q_door_infiltration = n × (door_area) × (air_changes) × 1.08 × ΔT

Typical values:

• n = number of bay doors
• door_area = 10 ft × 12 ft = 120 ft² (standard single-bay door)
• air_changes = 2-4 ACH for well-sealed doors, 6-10 ACH for older overhead doors
• Use outdoor design temperature, not building design temperature

Thermal recovery multiplier: Apply 1.25-1.50 factor to calculated capacity to ensure rapid temperature recovery after door operations.

Bay Door Strategies

Vestibule Design: Large stations benefit from drive-through bay configurations creating thermal vestibules:

• Apparatus enters front door, pulls through, exits rear door
• Interior training/maintenance bay isolated from exterior doors
• Reduces infiltration to occupied support spaces

Door Seals and Weather Stripping: Critical for thermal performance:

• Bottom seals with automatic threshold systems
• Perimeter gaskets along door tracks
• Properly maintained operator mechanisms ensuring full closure

Air Curtains: Supplemental strategy for frequently opened doors:

• Heated air curtain units above door openings
• Discharge velocity 1000-1500 FPM across door width
• Capacity sufficient to overcome infiltration pressure (typically 50-100 CFM per linear foot of door width)
• Most effective for doors opening less than 5 minutes per hour

Diesel Exhaust Removal Systems

Source Capture Requirements

NFPA 1500 (Standard on Fire Department Occupational Safety and Health Program) requires protection from diesel exhaust exposure. Effective systems employ direct-connect exhaust capture eliminating dispersal into bay atmosphere.

Exhaust Hose Systems: Connect directly to vehicle tailpipes:

• Flexible hose reels mounted at ceiling or floor level
• Hose diameter 3-5 inches matching vehicle exhaust pipe diameter
• Quick-connect nozzles sealed to tailpipe during apparatus warm-up
• Spring-loaded reels retract hose when apparatus departs

Magnetic Attachment Nozzles: Critical interface component:

• Magnetically attaches to vehicle exhaust pipe
• Positive connection prevents exhaust leakage
• Quick-release mechanism for rapid apparatus departure
• Temperature-resistant gaskets maintain seal

Exhaust System Design

Exhaust Fan Capacity: Size based on simultaneous apparatus operation:

Q_exhaust = (n_simultaneous) × (CFM_per_vehicle) × (diversity_factor)

Typical values:

• CFM_per_vehicle = 150-250 CFM depending on apparatus size
• Small apparatus (ambulances): 150 CFM
• Medium apparatus (pumpers): 200 CFM
• Large apparatus (aerials, tankers): 250 CFM
• diversity_factor = 0.6-0.8 for stations with more than 3 apparatus

Duct Sizing: Maintain exhaust velocity 2000-3000 FPM in collection mains:

• Individual vehicle drops: 800-1200 FPM
• Main collection headers: 2000-3000 FPM
• Higher velocity prevents condensate accumulation

System Configuration:

• Negative pressure system (fan at discharge end pulling through ductwork)
• Minimize horizontal duct runs (maximum 10 feet to vertical riser)
• Pitch horizontal sections minimum 1% toward condensate drains
• Exhaust discharge above roofline, minimum 10 feet from air intakes

Makeup Air: Exhaust system operation creates negative pressure requiring makeup air:

• Provide 90-100% of exhaust CFM as makeup air
• Heated makeup air (gas-fired or indirect heating)
• Introduce low in bay space to prevent short-circuiting to exhaust points
• Interlocked with exhaust fan operation

Alternative: Extraction Systems: Overhead boom-mounted extraction arms:

• Articulated arms with capture hoods position near tailpipe
• More flexible than hose reel systems but require operator positioning
• Typical capture hood flow rate 200-300 CFM per hood
• More common in maintenance facilities than active fire stations

Exhaust System Contamination Prevention

Bay Pressurization: Maintain bay areas at negative pressure relative to occupied spaces:

• Pressure differential -5 to -10 Pa relative to adjacent occupancies
• Prevents exhaust migration into offices, living quarters, training areas
• Requires continuous low-level exhaust when bay doors closed

Separate Ventilation Systems: Bay and occupied space ventilation must remain isolated:

• Dedicated bay exhaust fans (not shared with building HVAC)
• No return air pathways from bay to occupied space air handlers
• Transfer grilles between bay and adjacent spaces prohibited

Breathing Air Quality: Living quarters and offices require outdoor air free from exhaust contamination:

• Outdoor air intakes minimum 25 feet from apparatus bay doors
• Locate intakes on prevailing upwind side of building
• Minimum 10 feet above grade to avoid ground-level diesel emissions
• CO monitoring in outdoor air intakes with alarm at 9 ppm (per ASHRAE 62.1)

Living Quarters HVAC

System Design Requirements

Fire station living quarters operate continuously with personnel working 24-hour shifts. HVAC systems must provide residential-level comfort and individual zone control.

Temperature Control:

• Individual room thermostats for sleeping quarters
• Design temperature range 68-76°F (occupant adjustable)
• Night setback not applicable due to continuous occupancy
• Quiet operation essential for sleeping personnel

Ventilation Requirements: ASHRAE 62.1 classifies living quarters as residential occupancy:

• 15 CFM per person outdoor air minimum
• Continuous or intermittent ventilation acceptable
• Bedroom ventilation may use individual exhaust with passive makeup air

System Types:

Split Systems with Zoned Control: Common for smaller stations:

• Ductless mini-split systems for individual sleeping quarters
• Individual room control and quiet operation
• Heat pump operation provides heating and cooling
• Capacity 9,000-18,000 BTU/hr per sleeping room

Central Air Handling with VAV: Larger stations with multiple living areas:

• Central air handler serving living quarters zones
• VAV terminal units with reheat for individual rooms
• Dedicated outdoor air system (DOAS) with energy recovery
• Common areas on separate zones from sleeping quarters

Acoustic Requirements: Critical for sleeping quarters during day shifts:

• NC-25 to NC-30 maximum in sleeping quarters
• Duct silencers on supply and return near sleeping rooms
• Vibration isolation for all equipment
• Low-velocity ductwork (maximum 800 FPM in sleeping areas)

Kitchen and Dining Areas

Commercial Kitchen Ventilation: Stations with full kitchen facilities require Type I hoods:

• Exhaust rate determined by appliance type and duty (light, medium, heavy)
• Typical range: 200-400 CFM per linear foot of hood
• Listed grease filters and fire suppression system
• Direct makeup air to kitchen (80-100% of exhaust)

Residential Kitchen: Smaller stations with residential appliances:

• Type II hood or residential range hood sufficient
• Exhaust rate 100-150 CFM intermittent operation
• Recirculating hoods not recommended due to grease buildup

Dining Area HVAC: Follows commercial occupancy requirements:

• 7.5 CFM per person outdoor air (ASHRAE 62.1)
• Cooling load includes simultaneous occupancy and cooking equipment
• Separate zone control from sleeping quarters for temperature and hours of operation

24-Hour Occupancy Considerations

Continuous Operation Requirements

Fire stations never close. HVAC systems must operate reliably without interruption and allow maintenance without compromising occupant comfort.

Redundancy: Critical systems require backup capacity:

• Dual heating systems (combination of radiant floor and unit heaters)
• Redundant exhaust fans for diesel exhaust removal
• Automatic switchover for equipment failures
• Emergency generator capacity includes HVAC loads

Energy Efficiency: Continuous operation demands efficient design:

• High-efficiency heating and cooling equipment (minimum 90% AFUE boilers, 95%+ furnaces, 16 SEER cooling)
• Energy recovery ventilation (ERV) for outdoor air (60-70% sensible effectiveness minimum)
• LED lighting with occupancy controls in auxiliary spaces
• Programmable setback for administrative areas during night hours

Scheduling and Setback Strategies: Limited by continuous occupancy:

Maintenance Accessibility

Equipment Location: Facilitate routine maintenance without disrupting operations:

• Rooftop equipment preferred for noise isolation and accessibility
• Mechanical rooms separate from apparatus bays for contamination prevention
• Service access not requiring entry through occupied spaces
• Filter access and routine service points clearly labeled

Bypass and Isolation: Allow equipment servicing during occupancy:

• Isolation valves on all major equipment
• Bypass capability for pumps and key components
• Dual units where single-point failures unacceptable (exhaust fans, makeup air units)

Indoor Air Quality

CO and Diesel Particulate Control: Primary IAQ concern in fire stations:

• Continuous monitoring in apparatus bay (alarm at 35 ppm CO, action at 9 ppm)
• Separate ventilation systems prevent contamination migration
• Interlocked exhaust systems activate automatically with apparatus doors
• Regular filter replacement (quarterly minimum) in occupied space air handlers

MERV Filtration: Higher filtration protects personnel from outdoor and internal contaminants:

• MERV 13 minimum for living quarters and administrative areas
• MERV 11 minimum for apparatus bay makeup air
• Pre-filters extend final filter life in high-dust environments

Building Codes and Standards

Fire station design references multiple standards:

NFPA Standards:

• NFPA 1500: Fire Department Occupational Safety and Health Program (exhaust exposure limits)
• NFPA 92: Smoke Control Systems (if required for attached training facilities)

ASHRAE Standards:

• ASHRAE 62.1: Ventilation for Acceptable Indoor Air Quality
• ASHRAE 90.1: Energy Standard for Buildings (with exception allowances for 24/7 facilities)

IMC and Local Codes: International Mechanical Code governs system design and installation:

• Exhaust system materials and construction
• Gas-fired appliance venting and combustion air
• Makeup air requirements

State and Local Requirements: Many jurisdictions impose additional requirements:

• Minimum heating temperatures in apparatus bays
• Energy efficiency mandates (LED lighting, high-efficiency equipment)
• Seismic bracing and wind load requirements for rooftop equipment

Design Integration

Successful fire station HVAC design coordinates mechanical systems with architectural planning:

Architectural Coordination:

• Equipment rooms sized and located during schematic design
• Duct and pipe shaft locations coordinated with apparatus circulation
• Adequate ceiling height in apparatus bay for unit heaters and exhaust collection
• Mechanical chases from basement/rooftop equipment to occupied floors

Structural Coordination:

• Rooftop equipment loads provided early for structural design
• Radiant floor tubing placement coordinated with slab reinforcing and control joints
• Vibration isolation requirements communicated for equipment mounting

Electrical Coordination:

• Electrical service capacity includes HVAC loads (heating often largest load)
• Emergency generator capacity sized for critical HVAC (exhaust fans, minimum heating)
• BAS and controls integration with fire alarm and security systems

Plumbing Coordination:

• Hot water generation for kitchen, showers, and radiant heating may share equipment
• Condensate drainage from cooling equipment and exhaust system condensate
• Floor drains in apparatus bay located to avoid interference with radiant floor tubing

Sections