Seismic Bracing for HVAC Equipment

Seismic bracing for HVAC equipment prevents catastrophic failure and ensures life safety during seismic events. Proper restraint design accounts for both the equipment’s dynamic characteristics and the building’s seismic response, requiring coordination between mechanical systems, structural supports, and vibration isolation components.

Seismic Design Forces

Equipment seismic forces are calculated using the simplified method from ASCE 7:

Fp = (0.4 ap Sds Wp) / (Rp / Ip) × (1 + 2z/h)

Where:

• Fp = Seismic design force (lbs)
• ap = Component amplification factor (2.5 for mechanical equipment)
• Sds = Design spectral response acceleration (site-specific)
• Wp = Operating weight of equipment (lbs)
• Rp = Component response modification factor (2.5 for equipment, 6.0 for vibration isolated)
• Ip = Component importance factor (1.0 or 1.5)
• z = Height of component attachment above grade (ft)
• h = Average roof height of structure (ft)

Force Limits:

• Fp,max = 1.6 Sds Ip Wp
• Fp,min = 0.3 Sds Ip Wp

For a 2,500 lb rooftop unit at z = 40 ft, h = 40 ft, Sds = 1.0:

Fp = (0.4 × 2.5 × 1.0 × 2,500) / (2.5 / 1.0) × (1 + 2 × 40/40) = 2,500 × 1.0 × 3.0 = 3,000 lbs

Restraint Types and Applications

1. Direct Anchorage Systems

Equipment mounted rigidly to structural supports without vibration isolation.

Applications:

• Small packaged units (< 200 lbs)
• Non-rotating equipment
• Low-vibration applications

Attachment Methods:

• Cast-in-place anchor bolts (minimum 3/8" diameter)
• Post-installed expansion anchors (ICC-ES approved)
• Welded connections to structural steel

Design Considerations:

• Minimum four anchor points per equipment
• Edge distance ≥ 7 bolt diameters from concrete edges
• Anchor embedment per manufacturer’s seismic rating

2. Vibration-Isolated Equipment Restraints

Equipment on spring or elastomeric isolators requires specialized restraint to prevent excessive displacement during seismic events.

Restraint Components:

3. Seismic Snubber Design

Snubbers provide rigid restraint during seismic events while allowing normal thermal expansion and vibration isolation.

Types:

All-Directional Snubbers:

• Steel housing with clearance gap
• Engages in all horizontal directions
• Typical gap: 1/4" for normal operation

Unidirectional Snubbers:

• Restrain single axis of movement
• Used in pairs for bidirectional control
• Allow thermal growth perpendicular to restraint

Spring-Loaded Snubbers:

• Hydraulic or mechanical damping
• Adjustable engagement force
• Used for sensitive equipment

Snubber Force Calculation:

Number of snubbers = Fp / (Allowable snubber load × 0.7)

The 0.7 factor accounts for unequal load distribution.

Vibration Isolation Coordination

Seismic restraints must not compromise vibration isolation effectiveness.

Coordination Requirements:

1. Static Deflection Verification

   • Isolator deflection under operating load: δs
   • Seismic restraint clearance: δr ≥ 2 × δs
   • Prevents contact during normal operation

2. Natural Frequency Separation

   • Equipment natural frequency: fn = 188/√δs (Hz)
   • Building fundamental frequency: fb
   • Required: fn < 0.6 fb (avoid resonance)

3. Seismic Load Path

   • Isolators carry vertical seismic loads
   • Snubbers carry horizontal seismic loads
   • Housekeeping pad distributes forces to structure

Restraint Configuration Diagrams

Standard Four-Point Restraint

┌─────────────────────────────────┐
│         EQUIPMENT               │
│                                 │
│  ●─────────────────────────●   │  ● = Anchor/Snubber Location
│  │                         │   │
│  │                         │   │
│  │      Center of          │   │
│  │       Gravity           │   │
│  │                         │   │
│  ●─────────────────────────●   │
│                                 │
└─────────────────────────────────┘

Forces Applied at CG:
- Longitudinal: 100% Fp
- Transverse: 100% Fp
- Vertical: 0.2 Sds Wp (up or down)

Each Restraint Designed For:
- Horizontal: Fp / 4 (minimum)
- Actual: Use load combination analysis

Vibration-Isolated Equipment Detail

EQUIPMENT CURB/BASE
├─── Seismic Snubber (typ. 4 locations)
│    ├─── 1/4" operating clearance
│    └─── Rigid connection when engaged
│
├─── Vibration Isolator (typ. 4-8 locations)
│    ├─── Spring or elastomeric element
│    ├─── Built-in restraint (if applicable)
│    └─── Vertical load capacity
│
└─── Reinforced Housekeeping Pad
     ├─── Minimum 4" thick concrete
     ├─── #4 rebar @ 12" o.c. each way
     └─── Anchor bolts to structural deck

Load Transfer:
Normal Operation: Equipment → Isolators → Pad → Structure
Seismic Event: Equipment → Snubbers → Pad → Structure

Elevated Equipment on Steel Frame

      ┌──── Equipment ────┐
      │                   │
      └───────┬───────────┘
              │
    ┌─────────┴─────────┐
    │  Spring Isolator  │ (if required)
    └─────────┬─────────┘
              │
    ┌─────────┴─────────┐     Lateral Bracing:
    │   Equipment Curb  │ ◄─── - Horizontal angle braces
    └─────────┬─────────┘      - 30°-60° from horizontal
              │                 - Connected to rigid structure
    ┌─────────┴─────────┐
    │  Structural Frame │
    │   (W-beam/HSS)    │
    └─────────┬─────────┘
              │
         Building Structure

Brace Design:
- Tension/compression capacity ≥ 1.4 Fp
- Connection strength ≥ brace capacity
- Minimum 2 braces per orthogonal direction

Attachment Methods and Details

Concrete Anchorage

Cast-in-Place Anchors:

• Preferred method for new construction
• Minimum embedment: 12 bolt diameters
• Use anchor bolt templates for accuracy
• Grout base after equipment placement

Post-Installed Anchors:

• Required for retrofit applications
• Must have ICC-ES ESR for seismic applications
• Common types: expansion anchors, adhesive anchors, undercut anchors
• Installation inspection required

Concrete Requirements:

• Minimum compressive strength: 2,500 psi
• Edge distance: ≥ 7 bolt diameters
• Spacing: ≥ 4 bolt diameters
• Minimum slab thickness: 6 inches

Steel Structure Attachment

Connection Types:

Equipment Base Details

Bolted Equipment Base:

• Equipment base plate minimum thickness: 1/4"
• Bolt holes: 1/8" larger than bolt diameter
• Leveling nuts: double-nutted or tack-welded
• Grouting: non-shrink cementitious grout

Welded Connections:

• Base plate welded to structural steel
• Fillet welds: minimum 1/4" leg
• Weld design: E70XX electrodes typical
• Inspection: visual or UT per AWS D1.1

Certification and Documentation Requirements

Pre-Approval Certification

Equipment manufacturers may provide seismic certification:

Shake Table Testing:

• Per ICC-ES AC156 protocol
• Required Performance Level: Life Safety or Operational
• Certification includes: equipment model, weight range, mounting configuration

Analysis Certification:

• Finite element analysis of equipment structure
• Dynamic response verification
• Signed and sealed by licensed professional engineer

Installation Certification

Required Documentation:

1. Shop Drawings

   • Equipment layout and dimensions
   • Anchor bolt locations and sizes
   • Seismic restraint details
   • Isolator specifications

2. Structural Calculations

   • Seismic force calculations (Fp)
   • Anchor design and capacity verification
   • Base/curb structural adequacy
   • Load transfer to building structure

3. Installation Inspection

   • Anchor installation verification
   • Torque verification (typical: 75% of proof load)
   • Clearance verification for snubbers
   • Photographic documentation

4. Special Inspection Reports

   • Required for IBC Seismic Design Category C and above
   • Performed by approved special inspector
   • Documentation of anchor testing (if required)

Compliance Verification Checklist

• Seismic force calculation (Fp) completed and documented
• Equipment weight verified (nameplate or certified drawings)
• Anchor type and size specified (ICC-ES approved for seismic)
• Minimum four anchor points provided
• Edge distances and spacing verified
• Vibration isolation coordinated with seismic restraints
• Snubber clearances verified (1/4" to 1/2" typical)
• Housekeeping pad design completed (if required)
• Structural adequacy verified by engineer of record
• Installation inspected and documented
• Special inspection performed (if required by code)

Coordination with Other Systems

Electrical Connections:

• Provide flexible conduit for seismically-braced equipment
• Length: sufficient for seismic displacement + vibration
• Support conduit independently

Piping Connections:

• Flexible connectors required for vibration-isolated equipment
• Seismic separation joints at building expansion joints
• Pipe supports designed for seismic loads

Ductwork Connections:

• Canvas or flexible connections at equipment
• Independent seismic bracing of ductwork per SMACNA
• Clearance for equipment movement

References and Standards

• ASCE 7: Minimum Design Loads and Associated Criteria for Buildings and Other Structures (Chapter 13 - Seismic Design Requirements for Nonstructural Components)
• SMACNA: Seismic Restraint Manual: Guidelines for Mechanical Systems (Third Edition)
• ASHRAE: HVAC Applications Handbook (Chapter 61 - Seismic and Wind Restraint Design)
• IBC: International Building Code (Section 1613 - Earthquake Loads)
• CBC: California Building Code (additional stringent requirements for high-seismic zones)
• ICC-ES AC156: Acceptance Criteria for Seismic Certification by Shake-Table Testing of Nonstructural Components
• AWS D1.1: Structural Welding Code - Steel

Proper seismic restraint design and installation protects HVAC equipment investment, maintains building operability after seismic events, and ensures occupant safety. All installations in Seismic Design Categories C, D, E, and F require engineering calculations and special inspection to verify code compliance.

Sections