Equipment Certification for Seismic & Wind Resistance

Overview of Equipment Certification

HVAC equipment certification for seismic, wind, and flood resistance ensures that mechanical systems maintain structural integrity and functionality during extreme events. Certification from recognized agencies provides compliance verification, reduces liability, and meets code requirements in high-risk jurisdictions.

The certification process involves rigorous testing, analysis, and third-party verification of equipment performance under simulated seismic, wind, and environmental loads. Multiple certification bodies evaluate equipment using different protocols, each serving specific regulatory and performance requirements.

ICC-ES Certification Process

The International Code Council Evaluation Service (ICC-ES) provides the most widely recognized certification for building components in seismic regions. ICC-ES AC156 (Acceptance Criteria for Seismic Certification by Shake-Table Testing of Nonstructural Components) establishes protocols for shake table testing of HVAC equipment.

ICC-ES Certification Steps:

1. Pre-qualification analysis - Engineering calculations verify equipment can withstand design loads
2. Test protocol development - Create test plan conforming to AC156 requirements
3. Shake table testing - Subject equipment to triaxial seismic motion at certified facility
4. Performance evaluation - Verify functionality during and after seismic simulation
5. Report submission - Provide test data, calculations, and installation instructions
6. Evaluation report issuance - ICC-ES publishes ESR (Evaluation Service Report)

ICC-ES reports remain valid for three years and require renewal with updated documentation or additional testing if equipment design changes.

Shake Table Testing Procedures

Shake table testing simulates earthquake ground motion in three axes simultaneously, subjecting equipment to realistic seismic forces. Testing facilities use hydraulic actuators to reproduce time-history records from actual earthquakes or code-specified response spectra.

Test Specifications:

The Required Response Spectrum (RRS) for shake table testing follows AC156 requirements:

$$ \text{RRS} = a_p \cdot \frac{1 + z/h}{(T_p/T)^{2/3}} \cdot I_p $$

where:

• $a_p$ = component amplification factor (1.0 to 2.5)
• $z$ = height of component attachment point
• $h$ = structure height
• $T_p$ = component period
• $T$ = building fundamental period
• $I_p$ = component importance factor

Testing Protocol Elements:

• Frequency sweep - Identify resonant frequencies before full testing
• Exploratory test - 50% of design level to verify mounting and instrumentation
• Qualification test - 100% of RRS for five major earthquake cycles
• Functional verification - Equipment must operate during and after testing
• Damage assessment - Document any structural damage, leaks, or malfunctions

Testing must demonstrate that equipment remains anchored, operational connections stay intact, and the unit functions within acceptable parameters throughout the test sequence.

Certification Body Comparison

Different certification agencies serve distinct purposes in equipment qualification:

UL Certification for Mechanical Equipment

UL provides certification primarily focused on electrical safety and fire resistance. UL 1995 covers heating and cooling equipment, while UL 2021 addresses rooftop units specifically.

UL Certification Elements:

• Electrical safety testing for shock and fire hazards
• Temperature rise measurements under fault conditions
• Dielectric strength verification
• Flammability testing of materials and insulation
• Structural integrity under normal operating loads

UL certification requires ongoing factory surveillance with periodic inspections to ensure continued compliance with original test samples.

FM Global Approval

FM Global approval focuses on property loss prevention, particularly for large commercial and industrial facilities. FM 4430 (Heat and Smoke Venting) and FM 4470 (Single-Ply Membrane Roof Systems) cover equipment in high-wind and fire scenarios.

FM Approval Process:

1. Product examination - Initial testing at FM research campus
2. Engineering analysis - Review of design and manufacturing processes
3. Follow-up inspections - Quarterly or semi-annual factory audits
4. Installation review - Guidance on proper mounting and protection

FM Approved equipment receives lower insurance rates and meets requirements for properties insured by FM Global.

OSHPD Seismic Certification

California’s Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development (OSHPD) enforces stringent seismic requirements for hospital and essential facility equipment. OSHPD pre-approval or project-specific approval is mandatory for all nonstructural components.

OSHPD Approval Pathways:

• Pre-approved certification - Manufacturer obtains generic approval for product line
• Project-specific approval - Engineer submits calculations and test data for specific installation
• Seismic Calculation Checklist - Required documentation demonstrating seismic adequacy

OSHPD approval requires:

$$ F_p = \frac{0.4 \cdot a_p \cdot S_{DS} \cdot W_p}{R_p/I_p} \cdot \left(1 + 2 \cdot \frac{z}{h}\right) $$

subject to:

$$ F_{p,\text{max}} = 1.6 \cdot S_{DS} \cdot I_p \cdot W_p $$

$$ F_{p,\text{min}} = 0.3 \cdot S_{DS} \cdot I_p \cdot W_p $$

where:

• $S_{DS}$ = design spectral acceleration
• $W_p$ = component weight
• $R_p$ = component response modification factor
• $I_p$ = component importance factor
• $z/h$ = height factor ratio

IEEE 693 for Electrical Equipment

IEEE 693 (Recommended Practice for Seismic Design of Substations) applies to electrical components in power distribution systems, data centers, and critical facilities.

IEEE 693 Qualification Methods:

1. Shake table testing - Triaxial testing using specified response spectra
2. Analysis - Finite element modeling with peer review
3. Experience data - Documentation of successful performance in actual earthquakes

IEEE 693 defines seismic qualification levels:

• High Level - Peak ground acceleration 0.5g, for high seismic zones
• Moderate Level - Peak ground acceleration 0.25g, for moderate seismic zones

Testing must demonstrate equipment functionality during seismic events and verify no loss of structural integrity or safety-critical failures.

Certification Selection Strategy

Selecting appropriate certifications depends on project requirements, jurisdiction, and facility type:

• High seismic zones - ICC-ES AC156 certification essential for code compliance
• Healthcare facilities - OSHPD pre-approval or project-specific approval mandatory in California
• Insured properties - FM Global approval provides insurance benefits
• Electrical rooms and data centers - IEEE 693 qualification for critical electrical equipment
• All projects - UL certification baseline requirement for electrical safety

Multiple certifications may be necessary for complex projects. Equipment manufacturers increasingly offer products with ICC-ES, UL, and FM certifications to serve broad market requirements.

Installation and Documentation Requirements

Certification validity depends on proper installation per manufacturer’s instructions and certification body requirements. Installation documentation must include:

• Anchoring details matching certified configurations
• Vibration isolation specifications and seismic snubbers
• Piping flexibility and seismic separations
• Electrical conduit flexible connections
• Equipment spacing and clearances

Field modifications invalidate certifications unless approved by the certification body and project engineer. Special inspection during installation verifies compliance with certified installation procedures, particularly for OSHPD projects where special inspection is mandatory.

Related Topics:

• Seismic Design Criteria
• Seismic Bracing for Equipment
• Wind Load Design
• Resilient Design Strategies

Sections