Indoor Environment Research

Indoor Environment Research

Advanced indoor environment research integrates thermal comfort theory, air quality science, lighting physiology, and human-centered design to optimize occupant health, productivity, and satisfaction. Current research extends beyond traditional temperature and humidity control to address personalized environmental preferences, circadian rhythm support, and holistic indoor environmental quality metrics.

Thermal Comfort Research

PMV/PPD Models

The Predicted Mean Vote (PMV) and Predicted Percentage Dissatisfied (PPD) models, developed by P.O. Fanger, quantify thermal comfort based on metabolic rate, clothing insulation, air temperature, radiant temperature, air velocity, and relative humidity.

PMV calculation:

PMV = [0.303·e^(-0.036M) + 0.028]·L

Where:

• M = metabolic rate (W/m²)
• L = thermal load on the body (W/m²)

PMV Scale:

ISO 7730 recommends maintaining PMV between -0.5 and +0.5 for Category B comfort (PPD < 10%).

Adaptive Comfort Models

Adaptive comfort theory recognizes that occupants in naturally ventilated buildings accept wider temperature ranges through behavioral, physiological, and psychological adaptation.

ASHRAE 55 Adaptive Model:

T_comf = 0.31·T_pma(out) + 17.8°C

Where T_pma(out) = prevailing mean outdoor temperature.

Applicable conditions:

• Naturally conditioned spaces
• Occupants engaged in near-sedentary activity (1.0-1.3 met)
• Occupant control over operable windows
• Outdoor temperatures 10-33.5°C

Local Thermal Discomfort

Research identifies specific local discomfort mechanisms:

Draft risk calculation:

DR = (34 - T_a)·(v_a - 0.05)^0.62·(0.37·v_a·Tu + 3.14)

Where:

• T_a = air temperature (°C)
• v_a = mean air velocity (m/s)
• Tu = turbulence intensity (%)

Vertical temperature gradients: Maximum 3°C between ankle and head height (0.1-1.1 m) per ASHRAE 55.

Radiant asymmetry limits:

Indoor Air Chemistry

Gas-Phase Reactions

Indoor air contains complex mixtures of volatile organic compounds (VOCs), oxidants (ozone, hydroxyl radicals), and reaction products.

Ozone-terpene reactions:

Limonene + O₃ → formaldehyde + other aldehydes + ultrafine particles

Reaction rates depend on:

• Ozone concentration (outdoor infiltration, office equipment)
• Surface materials (carpets, wood, textiles emit terpenes)
• Air exchange rate
• Surface deposition velocities

Secondary Organic Aerosol Formation

Gas-phase oxidation reactions produce low-volatility products that partition to the particle phase, creating ultrafine particles (UFP) with diameters < 100 nm.

Health implications:

• UFP deposit efficiently in alveolar regions
• High surface area enables toxic compound adsorption
• Evade conventional filtration (MERV filters ineffective)

Mitigation strategies:

• Reduce ozone infiltration (activated carbon filters)
• Select low-emitting materials
• Increase ventilation during cleaning activities
• Avoid concurrent use of terpene-containing cleaners and ozone generators

Phthalate and Flame Retardant Emissions

Semi-volatile organic compounds (SVOCs) from building materials and furnishings partition between gas, particle, and surface phases.

Emission mechanisms:

• Direct evaporation from plastics
• Abrasion of surface coatings
• Re-emission from dust particles

Research shows dust ingestion as significant exposure pathway, particularly for children.

Personalized Ventilation Systems

Personalized ventilation delivers clean air directly to the breathing zone, enabling reduced ventilation rates for the overall space while maintaining individual air quality and thermal comfort.

Design Configurations

Desk-mounted systems:

• Supply air velocity: 0.2-0.4 m/s at 15-20 cm from face
• Temperature differential: 2-3°C below room temperature
• Flow rate: 10-20 L/s per person

Task-ambient conditioning:

• Reduced background ventilation (4-6 L/s·person)
• Personalized supply (10-15 L/s·person)
• Total outdoor air maintained at code minimum

Performance Metrics

Personal exposure effectiveness:

ε_p = (C_exhaust - C_breathing) / (C_exhaust - C_supply)

Values > 1.0 indicate superior performance versus mixing ventilation.

Research demonstrates:

• 50-70% reduction in inhaled contaminants
• Improved thermal comfort satisfaction (15-25% increase)
• Energy savings potential: 20-35% through raised cooling setpoints

Circadian Lighting Integration

Research establishes strong links between lighting spectrum, intensity, timing, and circadian rhythm regulation, with significant HVAC integration opportunities.

Melanopic Illuminance

Non-visual photoreceptors (intrinsically photosensitive retinal ganglion cells) respond maximally to blue-cyan light (460-480 nm).

Melanopic Equivalent Daylight Illuminance (mEDI):

Quantifies circadian-effective light exposure.

Design targets:

HVAC System Integration

Coordinated lighting-HVAC control strategies:

Morning stimulation:

• High-CCT lighting (5000-6500K)
• Cooler temperatures (20-21°C)
• Increased ventilation rates

Afternoon transition:

• Gradual CCT reduction (4000-3000K)
• Temperature increase (22-23°C)
• Maintain air quality

Evening wind-down:

• Warm lighting (< 3000K)
• Warmer temperatures permissible
• Reduced ventilation acceptable in low-occupancy periods

Research shows 10-15% productivity improvement and reduced sick building syndrome symptoms with coordinated circadian-HVAC control.

Biophilic Design Integration

Biophilic design incorporates natural elements, patterns, and processes into built environments, with measurable physiological and psychological benefits.

Living Walls and Indoor Plants

Air quality impacts:

Plants provide modest VOC removal through:

• Leaf uptake and metabolism
• Soil microorganism biodegradation
• Substrate adsorption

Realistic performance:

• Single plant: 0.1-1.0 μg/m³·h VOC removal
• High-density living walls: 10-100 μg/m³·h
• Insufficient as primary air cleaning strategy
• Valuable for psychological benefits

HVAC considerations:

Natural Ventilation Integration

Operable windows provide:

• Psychological connection to outdoors
• Occupant control (adaptive comfort)
• Free cooling opportunities

Mixed-mode design:

• Automatic HVAC shutdown at open windows (window switches)
• Weatherstation integration for nighttime purge cooling
• CO₂-based ventilation reset
• Occupant education on optimal operation

Research demonstrates 40-60% HVAC energy reduction in appropriate climates with well-designed mixed-mode systems.

Emerging Comfort Metrics

Multi-Domain Comfort Indices

Traditional metrics address thermal, visual, acoustic, and air quality domains independently. Integrated research develops holistic satisfaction models.

Weighted comfort index:

CI = w₁·TC + w₂·VC + w₃·AC + w₄·AQ

Where:

• TC = thermal comfort score
• VC = visual comfort score
• AC = acoustic comfort score
• AQ = air quality score
• w₁…w₄ = weighting factors (task/space dependent)

Wearable Sensor Integration

Real-time physiological monitoring enables:

Measured parameters:

• Skin temperature (multiple locations)
• Heart rate variability
• Electrodermal activity
• Physical activity level

Predictive comfort models:

Machine learning algorithms correlate physiological data with comfort votes, enabling:

• Individual comfort prediction accuracy > 80%
• Proactive HVAC adjustment
• Personalized setpoint optimization

Productivity-Based Metrics

Research quantifies HVAC performance through cognitive function testing:

Measured outcomes:

• Reaction time
• Working memory
• Attention span
• Decision-making accuracy

Temperature-productivity relationship:

Peak performance observed at:

• Office work: 21-22°C
• Light physical work: 18-20°C
• Heavy physical work: 15-18°C

Productivity decreases 2-4% per °C deviation from optimal.

Air quality-cognitive function:

CO₂ concentration impacts:

Recent research challenges traditional 1000 ppm limits, suggesting lower targets (600-800 ppm) for optimal cognitive performance.

Future Research Directions

Current investigation areas:

• Individual comfort prediction using AI/ML algorithms
• Microbiome impacts of building design and operation
• Virtual reality for comfort research and training
• Internet-of-Things sensor networks for granular environmental mapping
• Climate change adaptation strategies for naturally ventilated buildings
• Embodied carbon vs. operational energy tradeoffs in high-performance HVAC
• Post-pandemic indoor air quality standards evolution

Indoor environment research continues advancing toward occupant-centered, health-promoting, energy-efficient building operations through integrated thermal, air quality, lighting, and acoustic design strategies grounded in rigorous scientific investigation.

Sections