Natural Refrigerants

Natural refrigerants are substances that occur naturally in the environment and have been used as working fluids in refrigeration and heat pump systems. These refrigerants possess zero ozone depletion potential (ODP) and negligible or zero global warming potential (GWP), making them environmentally superior alternatives to synthetic refrigerants. The primary natural refrigerants include ammonia (R-717), carbon dioxide (R-744), hydrocarbons (R-290, R-600a, R-1270), and water (R-718).

Thermophysical Property Comparison

The selection of natural refrigerants depends on understanding their thermophysical characteristics relative to application requirements.

Ammonia (R-717)

Ammonia represents one of the oldest and most thermodynamically efficient refrigerants in industrial use. Its superior heat transfer characteristics and high latent heat of vaporization enable smaller heat exchanger surface areas compared to synthetic alternatives.

Thermodynamic Performance

Ammonia exhibits excellent volumetric refrigeration capacity due to its low molecular weight and high latent heat. At typical evaporating temperatures of -10°C and condensing temperatures of 35°C, ammonia systems achieve coefficient of performance (COP) values 5-10% higher than comparable HFC systems. The high critical temperature (132.3°C) allows operation across a wide range of condensing conditions without approaching transcritical operation.

The pressure-temperature relationship for ammonia results in moderate operating pressures. At -10°C evaporation, the saturation pressure is 291 kPa (absolute), while at 35°C condensing, pressure reaches 1352 kPa. These pressures remain within standard industrial equipment ratings.

Material Compatibility

Ammonia exhibits chemical incompatibility with copper and copper alloys, requiring steel or aluminum construction for all wetted components. Copper content above 2% in alloys leads to corrosion and formation of copper compounds. Standard materials include:

• Carbon steel for pressure vessels and piping
• Stainless steel (304, 316) for high-purity applications
• Aluminum for brazed plate heat exchangers
• Synthetic elastomers (Buna-N, neoprene) for seals

Safety Considerations

Ammonia carries ASHRAE Safety Group B2L classification (lower toxicity, lower flammability). The permeable exposure limit (PEL) is 25 ppm for 8-hour time-weighted average. Ammonia’s pungent odor provides inherent leak detection at concentrations as low as 5 ppm, well below harmful levels.

Flammability limits in air range from 15% to 28% by volume, requiring ignition source temperatures above 651°C. This narrow flammability range and high autoignition temperature result in low fire risk under normal operating conditions.

Refrigerant charge minimization strategies include:

• Liquid overfeed systems reducing charge by 30-50%
• Distributed refrigeration architectures
• Secondary loop systems with glycol or CO₂
• Enclosed machinery rooms with ventilation and detection

Applications

Ammonia dominates large-scale industrial refrigeration:

• Cold storage warehouses (charge quantities 2000-20,000 kg)
• Food processing facilities
• Ice rinks and arenas
• Petrochemical refrigeration
• Marine refrigeration systems

Carbon Dioxide (R-744)

Carbon dioxide operates in transcritical cycles for most HVAC applications due to its low critical temperature of 31.0°C. Below this temperature, CO₂ functions in subcritical vapor-compression cycles; above it, the high-pressure side operates in supercritical state where distinct phase change does not occur.

Transcritical Cycle Operation

In transcritical operation, heat rejection occurs at supercritical pressures (typically 8-13 MPa) through gas cooling rather than condensation. The COP of transcritical CO₂ systems depends critically on gas cooler exit temperature and pressure optimization. Optimal discharge pressure varies with ambient conditions according to:

P_optimal ≈ 2.6 × P_evap + (ambient temperature correction factor)

Systems require high-pressure rated components (up to 14 MPa design pressure) and specialized expansion devices capable of handling high pressure ratios (3:1 to 5:1).

Heat Transfer Characteristics

CO₂ exhibits exceptional heat transfer coefficients due to its low viscosity and high thermal conductivity. In the supercritical region, the specific heat varies significantly with temperature, creating a temperature glide during heat rejection that can be matched to heat sink temperature profiles for improved thermodynamic efficiency.

Evaporator heat transfer coefficients for CO₂ exceed those of R-404A by factors of 1.5 to 3, enabling compact heat exchanger designs. The high operating pressures result in high vapor densities, reducing compressor displacement requirements and pressure drop in suction lines.

System Architecture

Transcritical CO₂ systems incorporate specialized components:

• Flash gas bypass: Recovers expansion work and reduces compressor load by 5-15%
• Ejectors: Use expansion energy to pre-compress suction vapor, improving COP by 8-12%
• Parallel compression: Handles flash gas separately at intermediate pressure
• Internal heat exchangers: Subcool high-pressure liquid while superheating suction vapor

Applications

CO₂ systems excel in applications with:

• Simultaneous heating and cooling demands (supermarkets, heat pumps)
• Low evaporating temperatures (-30°C to -50°C) where efficiency advantages increase
• Distributed refrigeration loads (cascade systems, secondary loops)
• Heat pump water heating (COP > 4.0 achievable)

Hydrocarbons

Hydrocarbon refrigerants include propane (R-290), isobutane (R-600a), and propylene (R-1270). These refrigerants demonstrate thermodynamic properties similar to HFC refrigerants they replace, often serving as “drop-in” alternatives with minimal system modifications.

Thermodynamic Characteristics

Propane (R-290) properties closely match R-22, making it suitable for existing R-22 equipment with charge reduction of approximately 40-50%. The reduced charge results from higher refrigerating effect per unit mass and lower required mass flow rates.

Isobutane (R-600a) serves as replacement for R-134a in small hermetic systems, particularly domestic refrigerators and freezers. Its lower operating pressures reduce compressor work input while maintaining adequate volumetric capacity in small displacement compressors.

Flammability Management

Hydrocarbons carry ASHRAE Safety Group A3 classification (lower toxicity, higher flammability). Flammability limits for propane range from 2.1% to 9.5% by volume in air, with autoignition temperature of 470°C.

Charge limits prescribed by safety standards:

Safety provisions include:

• Leak detection with automatic ventilation
• Charge minimization through brazed plate heat exchangers
• Electrical equipment rated for explosive atmospheres (Zone 2)
• Secondary loops for large capacity requirements
• Machinery room isolation with explosion-proof ventilation

Material Compatibility

Hydrocarbons exhibit excellent compatibility with conventional refrigeration materials including copper, brass, steel, and aluminum. Standard mineral or alkylbenzene lubricants function effectively, unlike HFCs requiring polyolester (POE) oils.

Applications

Hydrocarbon refrigerants find application in:

• Domestic refrigerators and freezers (50-150 g charge)
• Commercial refrigeration display cases and reach-in coolers
• Vending machines and beverage coolers
• Small split air conditioning systems (<5 kW)
• Industrial process cooling with machinery room installation

Water (R-718)

Water serves as refrigerant in centrifugal chillers operating at evaporator temperatures above 4°C. The high latent heat and zero environmental impact make water ideal for specific applications despite operational constraints.

Operating Characteristics

Water’s high normal boiling point necessitates operation under high vacuum. At 4°C evaporator temperature, saturation pressure is only 0.81 kPa (absolute), requiring vacuum-tight construction and continuous purging of non-condensable gases. Condenser pressures at 30°C reach 4.24 kPa, still well below atmospheric.

The large specific volume of water vapor requires high displacement compressors. Two-stage centrifugal compressors with impeller tip speeds exceeding 200 m/s achieve necessary pressure ratios while handling high volume flows. Typical water chillers operate with:

• Evaporator pressure: 0.6-1.2 kPa
• Condenser pressure: 2.0-7.0 kPa
• Pressure ratio: 3:1 to 8:1
• COP: 5.5-7.0 (depending on lift)

Freeze Prevention

Water’s freezing point at 0°C requires rigorous freeze protection. Evaporator designs incorporate:

• Flooded tube bundles with refrigerant-side water flow
• Low water-side flow rates (∆T = 3-8°C)
• Freeze-stat protection with automatic shutdown
• Pumpdown cycles during shutdown
• Glycol solutions for temperatures below 4°C

Applications

Water chillers suit applications with:

• Chilled water temperatures ≥4°C (comfort cooling)
• Large cooling capacities (≥500 kW)
• Available heat rejection at moderate temperatures
• High-efficiency requirements justifying capital cost
• Geographic locations with water availability

Comparative Application Selection

Natural refrigerant selection depends on capacity requirements, operating temperatures, safety infrastructure, and regulatory environment.

The trend toward natural refrigerants accelerates due to phase-down regulations on high-GWP synthetic refrigerants under the Kigali Amendment to the Montreal Protocol. System designers increasingly specify natural refrigerants for new construction, particularly in industrial and commercial refrigeration where safety infrastructure and trained personnel support their implementation.

Regulatory Framework

Natural refrigerants fall under multiple regulatory jurisdictions:

• ASHRAE Standard 15: Mechanical refrigeration system safety requirements
• ASHRAE Standard 34: Refrigerant safety classification and concentration limits
• ISO 5149: Refrigerating systems and heat pumps with flammable refrigerants
• IEC 60335 series: Household appliance safety with flammable refrigerant limits
• EPA SNAP Program: Acceptable substitutes for ozone-depleting substances

Local building codes and fire codes impose additional restrictions on refrigerant quantities and installation requirements. Many jurisdictions now provide incentives for natural refrigerant adoption through energy efficiency programs and refrigerant transition funding.

Sections