Classifications

Refrigerants are classified based on chemical composition, environmental impact, flammability characteristics, and toxicity levels. The evolution from chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) through hydrochlorofluorocarbons (HCFCs) to hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs), hydrofluoroolefins (HFOs), and natural refrigerants reflects the progression toward environmentally sustainable and thermodynamically efficient working fluids.

ASHRAE Standard 34 Classification System

ASHRAE Standard 34 provides the nomenclature and safety classification framework for refrigerants worldwide. The designation system uses an alphanumeric code that identifies the chemical family and molecular structure.

Numbering Convention

The refrigerant number reveals the chemical composition:

Halogenated Compounds (Rxyz):

• x = number of carbon atoms minus 1 (zero if omitted)
• y = number of hydrogen atoms plus 1
• z = number of fluorine atoms
• Chlorine atoms = 2(x+1) + 2 - y - z

For example, R-134a contains 2 carbon atoms (1+1), 2 hydrogen atoms (2-1+1), and 4 fluorine atoms.

Isomers are designated with lowercase letters (a, b, c) in order of increasing symmetry. R-134a is the most symmetric isomer of tetrafluoroethane.

Chemical Classifications

Chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs)

CFCs are fully halogenated compounds containing carbon, chlorine, and fluorine with no hydrogen atoms. The absence of hydrogen bonds renders them chemically stable in the troposphere, allowing transport to the stratosphere where UV radiation releases chlorine atoms that catalytically destroy ozone.

Characteristics:

• Zero ozone depletion potential (ODP) = 1.0 (reference substance)
• High global warming potential (GWP): 4,600-10,900
• Excellent thermodynamic properties
• Non-flammable
• Production banned under Montreal Protocol (1989)

Common CFCs:

Hydrochlorofluorocarbons (HCFCs)

HCFCs contain hydrogen atoms that make them reactive in the troposphere, resulting in shorter atmospheric lifetimes and reduced ozone depletion compared to CFCs. The carbon-hydrogen bond is susceptible to attack by hydroxyl radicals (OH), limiting stratospheric transport.

Characteristics:

• ODP: 0.01-0.11 (significantly lower than CFCs)
• GWP: 76-2,270
• Transitional replacements for CFCs
• Phase-out scheduled under Montreal Protocol
• Class A1 safety classification (low toxicity, non-flammable)

Common HCFCs:

R-22 dominated residential and light commercial air conditioning for decades. Its phase-out accelerated the development of R-410A and other HFC alternatives.

Hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs)

HFCs contain only hydrogen, fluorine, and carbon atoms. The absence of chlorine eliminates ozone depletion, but carbon-fluorine bonds create strong infrared absorption, resulting in high GWP values. HFCs became the primary CFC and HCFC replacements but now face restrictions under the Kigali Amendment.

Characteristics:

• ODP = 0 (no chlorine)
• GWP: 12-14,800
• Widely used in current systems
• Being phased down under Kigali Amendment (2016)
• Various safety classifications (A1, A2L)

Common HFCs:

R-410A operates at significantly higher pressures than R-22 (design pressure 450-550 psig vs 300-350 psig), requiring redesigned equipment and components.

Hydrofluoroolefins (HFOs)

HFOs are unsaturated organic compounds containing carbon double bonds (C=C) that make them reactive in the troposphere. The double bond enables attack by hydroxyl radicals, resulting in atmospheric lifetimes measured in days rather than years. This reactivity dramatically reduces GWP while maintaining zero ODP.

Characteristics:

• ODP = 0
• GWP: <1 to ~300
• Short atmospheric lifetime (11-33 days)
• Mildly flammable (A2L classification)
• Fourth-generation refrigerants
• Current focus for new equipment

Common HFOs:

The A2L classification indicates lower flammability with burning velocity <10 cm/s and heat of combustion <19 MJ/kg. These refrigerants require specific equipment design considerations and installation practices.

Natural Refrigerants

Natural refrigerants existed in Earth’s atmosphere before the development of synthetic compounds. They offer zero or negligible ODP and GWP, but present specific safety or efficiency challenges that limited historical adoption. Modern equipment design has overcome many traditional limitations.

Hydrocarbons (HCs):

Propane (R-290), isobutane (R-600a), and propylene (R-1270) provide excellent thermodynamic properties with zero ODP and GWP <5. The carbon-hydrogen bonds are highly flammable (A3 classification), requiring charge limits, leak detection, and explosion-proof equipment.

Ammonia (R-717):

NH₃ offers superior thermodynamic efficiency with zero ODP and GWP. The high latent heat of vaporization (1,371 kJ/kg at 0°C) and excellent heat transfer properties make it ideal for large industrial systems. Toxicity (B2L classification) and incompatibility with copper require specific design approaches.

Characteristics:

• Operating pressures similar to R-22
• Coefficient of performance 10-15% higher than HFCs
• Leak detection simplified by pungent odor
• Requires steel or stainless steel piping
• IIAR standards govern industrial applications

Carbon Dioxide (R-744):

CO₂ operates as a subcritical vapor-compression refrigerant or transcritical cycle above the critical point (31.1°C, 73.8 bar). The high operating pressures (up to 140 bar) require specialized components but enable compact equipment design.

Characteristics:

• GWP = 1 (negligible compared to anthropogenic emissions)
• Non-toxic, non-flammable (A1 classification)
• Excellent volumetric capacity
• Used in cascade systems, heat pumps, and CO₂ booster systems
• Superior performance in cold climates for heat pump applications

Water (R-718) and Air (R-729):

Water serves as the refrigerant in absorption chillers and steam jet refrigeration systems. Extremely low pressures (below atmospheric at typical evaporator temperatures) and high specific volume limit mechanical vapor compression applications. Air is used in specialized cryogenic and aircraft applications.

Safety Classifications

ASHRAE Standard 34 assigns two-character safety classifications based on toxicity and flammability:

Toxicity (First Character):

• Class A: Lower toxicity (OEL ≥400 ppm)
• Class B: Higher toxicity (OEL <400 ppm)

Flammability (Second Character):

• Class 1: No flame propagation
• Class 2L: Lower flammability (burning velocity <10 cm/s)
• Class 2: Flammable (burning velocity 10-100 cm/s)
• Class 3: Higher flammability (burning velocity >10 cm/s, LFL <3.5%)

Environmental Impact Metrics

Ozone Depletion Potential (ODP):

ODP quantifies stratospheric ozone destruction relative to R-11 (ODP = 1.0). The metric accounts for the number of chlorine or bromine atoms, molecular weight, and atmospheric lifetime. Compounds with C-H bonds have lower ODP due to tropospheric breakdown.

Global Warming Potential (GWP):

GWP measures radiative forcing over a specified time horizon (typically 100 years) relative to CO₂ (GWP = 1). The metric integrates infrared absorption strength and atmospheric lifetime. HFCs have high GWP due to strong C-F bond absorption in the 1,000-1,300 cm⁻¹ atmospheric window.

Total Equivalent Warming Impact (TEWI):

TEWI = (GWP × L × n × m) + (n × Eannual × β)

Where:

• L = leakage rate (fraction per year)
• n = system lifetime (years)
• m = refrigerant charge (kg)
• Eannual = annual energy consumption (kWh)
• β = CO₂ emission factor for electricity generation (kg CO₂/kWh)

TEWI analysis reveals that indirect emissions from energy consumption often exceed direct refrigerant emissions, emphasizing the importance of system efficiency.

Life Cycle Climate Performance (LCCP):

LCCP extends TEWI by including manufacturing emissions, refrigerant production, transportation, service impacts, and end-of-life disposal. This comprehensive metric enables comparison of different technologies across their complete lifecycle.

Regulatory Framework

Montreal Protocol (1987, amended 2016):

• Phase-out of CFCs (complete)
• Phase-out of HCFCs (ongoing)
• Kigali Amendment: Phase-down of HFCs (85% reduction by 2047 for developed countries)

European F-Gas Regulation (EU 517/2014):

• Progressive phase-down of HFC quota
• Equipment bans based on GWP thresholds
• Service restrictions for high-GWP refrigerants
• Mandatory leak detection and reporting

AIM Act (USA, 2020):

• 85% reduction in HFC production and consumption by 2036
• Technology transitions established by equipment sector
• Allocation system for HFC allowances

These regulations drive the transition toward lower-GWP refrigerants across all applications, accelerating adoption of HFOs, natural refrigerants, and alternative technologies.

Sections