Freezing Methods Food

Food freezing methods determine product quality, freezing rate, energy consumption, and capital investment requirements. The selection of freezing technology depends on product characteristics, production capacity, quality specifications, and economic constraints.

Freezing Rate Classification

Freezing methods are categorized by the rate at which product temperature passes through the critical zone (0°C to -5°C where maximum ice crystal formation occurs):

The freezing rate directly affects product quality through ice crystal morphology. Rapid freezing produces numerous small intracellular ice crystals, minimizing cell membrane damage and drip loss during thawing.

Air Blast Freezing

Air blast freezing uses forced convection with refrigerated air at -30°C to -40°C and velocities from 1.5 to 6 m/s. Heat transfer occurs primarily through convection with the surface heat transfer coefficient:

h = 5.7 + 3.8v

Where h is the convective heat transfer coefficient (W/m²·K) and v is air velocity (m/s).

Tunnel Freezers

Continuous or batch tunnel freezers convey product on belts, trays, or carts through a refrigerated air stream. Design configurations include:

Straight-Through Tunnels: Product moves linearly through refrigerated zone with air flowing parallel (co-current), counter-current, or perpendicular to product flow.

Spiral Freezers: Belt forms vertical spiral within insulated enclosure. Airflow typically perpendicular to belt with vertical distribution plenum. Advantages include compact footprint (0.3-0.5 m² per ton/day capacity) and continuous operation.

Fluidized Bed Freezers: High-velocity upward air (4-6 m/s) suspends small particulate products (peas, berries, diced vegetables) in pseudo-fluidized state. Provides individual quick freezing (IQF) with excellent heat transfer coefficients (80-120 W/m²·K) but limited to specific product geometries.

Blast Room Freezers

Static air blast rooms circulate refrigerated air over product arranged on racks or pallets. Typical air velocities range from 1.5 to 3 m/s with evaporator temperatures at -35°C to -42°C. Loading density affects freezing uniformity and must maintain adequate air channels.

Plate Freezing

Plate freezers achieve rapid heat transfer through direct conduction between refrigerated metal plates and product. Aluminum or stainless steel plates contain internal refrigerant passages with evaporating refrigerant at -35°C to -45°C.

Heat transfer coefficient for plate contact ranges from 150 to 250 W/m²·K, significantly higher than air blast methods. Effective heat transfer requires:

• Uniform product thickness (±5 mm variation maximum)
• Adequate plate pressure (0.7-2 kPa) to ensure contact
• Minimal air gaps at product-plate interface
• Product packaging that conforms under pressure

Horizontal Plate Freezers

Stacked horizontal plates in vertical arrangement with hydraulic closure system. Typical configurations include 12-24 plates with 50-150 mm spacing. Product loaded manually or automatically on each shelf.

Advantages:

• High heat transfer efficiency
• Compact installation
• Low dehydration (product enclosed during freezing)
• Suitable for packaged rectangular products

Limitations:

• Labor-intensive loading/unloading
• Requires uniform product geometry
• Not suitable for irregular shapes

Vertical Plate Freezers

Parallel vertical plates with product loaded between adjacent surfaces. Primarily used for freezing fish blocks, where liquid product is poured into the cavity and solidifies against refrigerated plates.

Cryogenic Freezing

Cryogenic systems use direct contact with liquefied gases (nitrogen at -196°C or carbon dioxide at -78°C) to achieve ultra-rapid freezing rates. The phase change of cryogen from liquid to gas extracts latent heat from the product.

Liquid Nitrogen Freezing

Nitrogen provides 199 kJ/kg latent heat of vaporization plus 200 kJ/kg sensible heat as gas warms from -196°C to product equilibrium temperature. Total refrigeration effect approximately 400 kJ/kg of liquid nitrogen.

Theoretical nitrogen consumption:

m_N₂ = (m_p × c_p × ΔT) / (h_fg + c_g × ΔT_gas)

Where:

• m_N₂ = nitrogen mass required (kg)
• m_p = product mass (kg)
• c_p = product specific heat (kJ/kg·K)
• ΔT = product temperature change (K)
• h_fg = nitrogen latent heat (199 kJ/kg)
• c_g = nitrogen gas specific heat (1.04 kJ/kg·K)
• ΔT_gas = gas temperature rise (K)

Actual consumption typically 1.2-1.8 kg LN₂ per kg product frozen due to system losses and incomplete heat recovery.

Liquid Carbon Dioxide Freezing

CO₂ sublimates from solid phase (-78°C) or evaporates from liquid phase under pressure. Applied as liquid spray that partially converts to dry ice snow upon expansion through nozzles. Refrigeration effect approximately 570 kJ/kg CO₂.

Advantages over liquid nitrogen:

• Lower cost (40-60% of LN₂ price)
• Higher refrigeration efficiency per unit mass

Disadvantages:

• Higher sublimation temperature (-78°C vs -196°C)
• Slower freezing rates
• Requires pressure storage and handling equipment

Cryogenic System Configurations

Spray Freezers: Direct spray of liquid cryogen onto product surface as it travels through insulated tunnel. Separate pre-cooling and freezing zones optimize cryogen usage.

Immersion Freezers: Product submerged in liquid nitrogen bath for maximum heat transfer. Limited to products in impermeable packaging or those compatible with nitrogen contact.

Cabinet Freezers: Batch system with controlled cryogen injection into insulated chamber. Manual or semi-automatic operation for low production rates.

Immersion Freezing

Direct immersion in refrigerated liquid medium (brines, glycol solutions, or aqueous salt solutions) provides high heat transfer coefficients (200-800 W/m²·K) through convective contact.

Brine Immersion Systems

Common brines include:

• Sodium chloride solutions (eutectic at -21°C, 23.3% concentration)
• Calcium chloride solutions (eutectic at -51°C, 29.8% concentration)
• Sodium chloride/calcium chloride blends

Heat transfer coefficient in agitated brine:

h = 230 × v^0.8

Where v is relative brine-to-product velocity (m/s).

Challenges:

• Brine absorption into product (0.5-2% weight gain)
• Corrosion of equipment
• Sanitation and contamination control
• Environmental disposal of spent brine

Glycol Immersion

Propylene glycol solutions (food-grade) at concentrations of 35-50% provide freezing points from -20°C to -35°C without product absorption issues. Higher viscosity reduces heat transfer coefficient compared to brines.

Applications limited to packaged products or those where glycol contact is acceptable.

Freezing Method Comparison

Selection Criteria

Freezing method selection requires analysis of multiple factors:

Product Characteristics:

• Geometry and size uniformity
• Surface area to volume ratio
• Moisture content and composition
• Packaging requirements
• Target frozen temperature
• Acceptable quality loss

Production Requirements:

• Throughput capacity (kg/hr or tons/day)
• Batch vs. continuous operation
• Product changeover frequency
• Available floor space
• Integration with upstream/downstream processes

Economic Factors:

• Capital budget constraints
• Energy costs (electricity, cryogen, thermal utilities)
• Labor availability and costs
• Maintenance requirements
• Product value and quality premiums

Regulatory Compliance:

• Food safety standards (HACCP, SQF, BRC)
• Sanitation design (3-A, EHEDG)
• Environmental regulations
• Worker safety requirements

High-value products justify cryogenic systems for superior quality retention. High-volume commodity products typically use mechanical refrigeration (air blast or plate) to minimize operating costs. Many facilities employ hybrid systems combining cryogenic pre-cooling with mechanical finish freezing to optimize both quality and economics.

Heat Transfer Calculations

The freezing time for a given method can be estimated using Plank’s equation modified for practical conditions:

t = (ρ × L_f / (T_m - T_f)) × (P_a/h + R_a/(2k))

Where:

• t = freezing time (s)
• ρ = product density (kg/m³)
• L_f = latent heat of fusion (334 kJ/kg for water)
• T_m = initial freezing point (°C)
• T_f = freezing medium temperature (°C)
• P = product thickness (m)
• a = product dimension factor (0.5 for infinite slab, 0.25 for infinite cylinder, 0.167 for sphere)
• h = surface heat transfer coefficient (W/m²·K)
• R = product geometry factor (1/2 for slab, 1/4 for cylinder, 1/6 for sphere)
• k = thermal conductivity of frozen product (W/m·K)

This simplified approach provides reasonable estimates for single-phase freezing. More accurate predictions require numerical methods accounting for temperature-dependent properties and multi-phase heat transfer.

Sections