Pipe Flow

Pipe flow analysis forms the foundation for hydronic system design in HVAC applications. Understanding flow regime classification, friction characteristics, and pressure drop mechanisms enables accurate system sizing and performance prediction.

Reynolds Number and Flow Regime Classification

The Reynolds number (Re) characterizes flow regime by quantifying the ratio of inertial forces to viscous forces:

Re = ρVD/μ = VD/ν

Where:

• ρ = fluid density (lbm/ft³ or kg/m³)
• V = mean velocity (ft/s or m/s)
• D = pipe inside diameter (ft or m)
• μ = dynamic viscosity (lbm/ft·s or Pa·s)
• ν = kinematic viscosity (ft²/s or m²/s)

Flow regime boundaries:

• Laminar flow: Re < 2,300
• Transitional flow: 2,300 < Re < 4,000
• Turbulent flow: Re > 4,000

HVAC hydronic systems typically operate in the turbulent regime (Re = 10,000 to 100,000) to ensure adequate heat transfer and prevent stratification. Laminar flow occurs only in small-diameter tubing or high-viscosity fluids at low velocities.

Darcy-Weisbach Equation

The Darcy-Weisbach equation provides the most accurate method for calculating frictional pressure drop in pipe flow:

ΔP = f × (L/D) × (ρV²/2)

or in head loss form:

h_f = f × (L/D) × (V²/2g)

Where:

• ΔP = pressure drop (lbf/ft² or Pa)
• f = Darcy friction factor (dimensionless)
• L = pipe length (ft or m)
• D = pipe inside diameter (ft or m)
• h_f = head loss (ft or m)
• g = gravitational acceleration (32.2 ft/s² or 9.81 m/s²)

The friction factor f depends on Reynolds number and relative roughness (ε/D), requiring iterative solution methods or graphical correlation.

Friction Factor Determination

Laminar Flow (Re < 2,300)

For laminar flow, the friction factor depends only on Reynolds number:

f = 64/Re

This relationship is exact and applies to all pipe materials and surface conditions.

Turbulent Flow (Re > 4,000)

Friction factor determination requires correlation or graphical methods accounting for both Reynolds number and pipe roughness.

Colebrook-White equation (implicit):

1/√f = -2.0 log₁₀[(ε/D)/3.7 + 2.51/(Re√f)]

This equation requires iterative solution due to f appearing on both sides.

Swamee-Jain equation (explicit approximation):

f = 0.25 / [log₁₀(ε/3.7D + 5.74/Re^0.9)]²

Accurate to within 1% of Colebrook-White for 4,000 < Re < 10⁸ and 10⁻⁶ < ε/D < 10⁻².

Typical absolute roughness values (ε):

• Commercial steel: 0.00015 ft (0.046 mm)
• Drawn copper: 0.000005 ft (0.0015 mm)
• PVC/plastic: 0.000005 ft (0.0015 mm)
• Cast iron (new): 0.00085 ft (0.26 mm)
• Cast iron (aged): 0.0085 ft (2.6 mm)

Moody Diagram Application

The Moody diagram provides graphical correlation of friction factor as a function of Reynolds number and relative roughness (ε/D). The diagram displays:

• Laminar region: straight line following f = 64/Re
• Critical zone: transitional flow region
• Turbulent region: curves for constant ε/D values
• Fully rough zone: horizontal asymptotes where f becomes independent of Re

The Moody diagram enables quick friction factor estimation without iterative calculations, though computer-based methods using explicit equations offer greater precision for design applications.

Minor Losses in Piping Systems

Minor losses occur at fittings, valves, changes in flow area, and other components. Despite the terminology, these losses often constitute 25-50% of total system pressure drop in HVAC applications with complex piping networks.

Resistance Coefficient Method

ΔP = K × (ρV²/2)

or in head loss form:

h_m = K × (V²/2g)

Where K = resistance coefficient (dimensionless) specific to each component.

Representative K-factors:

• 90° threaded elbow: K = 1.5
• 90° long-radius elbow: K = 0.6
• Tee (through-flow): K = 0.4
• Tee (branch flow): K = 1.8
• Gate valve (fully open): K = 0.15
• Globe valve (fully open): K = 10.0
• Sudden expansion: K = [1 - (A₁/A₂)]²
• Sudden contraction: K = 0.5[1 - (A₂/A₁)]

Equivalent Length Method

Minor losses can alternatively be expressed as equivalent lengths of straight pipe producing equal pressure drop:

L_eq = K × (D/f)

This method simplifies hand calculations by consolidating all losses into a single friction factor calculation using total equivalent length.

Total System Pressure Drop

Total pressure drop combines frictional losses in straight pipe and minor losses at components:

ΔP_total = ΔP_friction + ΣΔP_minor

ΔP_total = f(L/D)(ρV²/2) + ΣK(ρV²/2)

ΔP_total = (ρV²/2)[fL/D + ΣK]

This formulation enables systematic pressure drop calculation for complex piping networks.

Design Velocity Recommendations

ASHRAE Handbook—Fundamentals provides velocity guidelines balancing pressure drop, noise, and erosion:

Water systems:

• 2-4 ft/s (0.6-1.2 m/s): distribution piping
• 4-10 ft/s (1.2-3.0 m/s): main headers
• 8-12 ft/s (2.4-3.7 m/s): pump suction/discharge

Glycol solutions:

• Reduce velocities by 10-15% due to increased viscosity

Velocities exceeding 12 ft/s (3.7 m/s) risk erosion-corrosion in copper systems. Velocities below 2 ft/s (0.6 m/s) may allow air separation and sediment deposition.

Pressure Drop Calculation Procedure

1. Determine fluid properties at operating temperature (ρ, μ, ν)
2. Calculate flow velocity from volumetric flow rate and pipe diameter: V = Q/A
3. Calculate Reynolds number to confirm flow regime
4. Determine relative roughness ε/D for pipe material and condition
5. Calculate friction factor using Colebrook-White or Swamee-Jain equation
6. Calculate frictional pressure drop using Darcy-Weisbach equation
7. Identify all fittings and valves in the piping section
8. Calculate minor losses using K-factors or equivalent lengths
9. Sum all pressure drops to determine total system requirement

This systematic approach ensures accurate pump selection and system performance prediction.

Practical Considerations

Aging effects: Pipe roughness increases over time due to corrosion, scale formation, and biofilm growth. Design calculations should incorporate aging factors for long-term performance, particularly in steel and cast iron systems. Copper systems maintain relatively constant roughness characteristics.

Temperature effects: Fluid viscosity decreases significantly with temperature increase, reducing both Reynolds number and friction factor. Pressure drop in hot water systems can be 30-50% lower than equivalent cold water systems at identical flow rates.

Non-Newtonian fluids: Glycol concentrations above 30% and certain heat transfer fluids exhibit non-Newtonian behavior, requiring modified friction factor correlations beyond standard equations.

Accuracy requirements: Pressure drop calculations accurate to within ±10% are generally sufficient for HVAC system design. Precision beyond this level is unwarranted given uncertainties in pipe roughness, fitting losses, and actual operating conditions.

Standards References

• ASHRAE Handbook—Fundamentals, Chapter 3: Fluid Flow
• ASHRAE Handbook—HVAC Systems and Equipment, Chapter 44: Hydronic Heating and Cooling System Design
• ASME B31.9: Building Services Piping
• Hydraulic Institute Standards for Pump Piping

Sections