Electric Resistance Heating

Electric Resistance Heating Fundamentals

Electric resistance heating converts electrical energy directly to heat through resistive elements. Unlike combustion systems, resistance heating achieves 100% conversion efficiency at the device level, though source energy efficiency including generation and transmission typically ranges 30-40% when accounting for power plant losses.

Applications include zone heating, supplemental heat, and primary heating in temperate climates or buildings without fossil fuel infrastructure. Heat output ranges from 250 watts (850 BTU/hr) for small units to 6,000 watts (20,500 BTU/hr) for large baseboard or wall systems.

Operating Principles

Joule Heating

Fundamental Physics Electric current through resistive conductor generates heat according to Joule’s law:

$$P = I^2 R = \frac{V^2}{R}$$

Where:

• $P$ = power dissipated as heat (watts)
• $I$ = current (amperes)
• $R$ = resistance (ohms)
• $V$ = voltage (volts)

For 240V system with 10-ohm element: $P = (240)^2 / 10 = 5,760$ watts

Resistive Element Materials

Nichrome (Nickel-Chromium Alloy)

• Composition: 80% nickel, 20% chromium
• Operating temperature: Up to 2,000°F
• Resistivity: 108-110 μΩ·cm
• Oxidation resistance: Excellent
• Application: Open coil and sheathed elements

Steel Sheathed Elements Nichrome or iron-chromium-aluminum wire in steel sheath with magnesium oxide insulation:

• Sheath temperature: 400-800°F
• Thermal response: Moderate (thermal mass of sheath)
• Durability: Extended life in protected environment
• Application: Baseboard, wall heaters, radiant panels

Carbon Fiber Elements Modern radiant heating panels:

• Operating temperature: 300-500°F
• Infrared emission spectrum optimized for human comfort
• Rapid response time
• Lower element temperature reduces fire risk

Heat Distribution Mechanisms

Convective Heating

Natural Convection Temperature differential drives air circulation:

$$Q_{conv} = h A (T_s - T_a)$$

Where:

• $Q_{conv}$ = convective heat transfer (W)
• $h$ = convection coefficient (5-12 W/m²·K for natural convection)
• $A$ = surface area (m²)
• $T_s$ = surface temperature (K)
• $T_a$ = ambient air temperature (K)

Baseboard heaters rely primarily on natural convection with heated air rising along element fins.

Forced Convection Fan increases convection coefficient to 25-80 W/m²·K:

• Faster space heating response
• Better air mixing and temperature uniformity
• Noise generation: 35-55 dBA
• Power consumption: 25-100 watts for fan motor

Wall heaters and unit heaters use forced convection for compact design and rapid heat delivery.

Radiant Heating

Infrared Radiation Electromagnetic energy transfer without air heating:

$$Q_{rad} = \epsilon \sigma A (T_s^4 - T_r^4)$$

Where:

• $\epsilon$ = surface emissivity (0.85-0.95 for typical panels)
• $\sigma$ = Stefan-Boltzmann constant (5.67×10⁻⁸ W/m²·K⁴)
• $A$ = radiating surface area (m²)
• $T_s$ = surface absolute temperature (K)
• $T_r$ = surrounding surface temperature (K)

Comfort Advantages Radiant heating provides comfort at lower air temperatures:

• Mean radiant temperature (MRT) impact on perceived comfort
• 2-3°F air temperature reduction maintains equal comfort
• Reduced stratification in high-ceiling spaces
• Direct heating of occupants and surfaces

System Types and Applications

Comparison of Electric Heating Methods

Sizing and Selection

Heat Loss Calculation Required electric heating capacity:

$$P_{required} = \frac{UA(T_i - T_o) + 0.33 \cdot V \cdot ACH \cdot (T_i - T_o)}{3.413}$$

Where:

• $P_{required}$ = required electric power (watts)
• $U$ = overall heat transfer coefficient (BTU/hr·ft²·°F)
• $A$ = envelope area (ft²)
• $T_i$, $T_o$ = indoor/outdoor design temperatures (°F)
• $V$ = volume (ft³)
• $ACH$ = air changes per hour
• 3.413 = conversion factor (BTU/hr to watts)

Watt Density Guidelines

• Well-insulated (R-30+ walls, R-50+ ceiling): 8-10 watts/ft²
• Standard insulation (R-19 walls, R-38 ceiling): 10-12 watts/ft²
• Poorly insulated: 12-15 watts/ft²
• High glazing areas: Add 100-200 watts per window

Electrical Service Requirements

Circuit Sizing Continuous loads require conductor and breaker rated 125% of connected load:

$$I_{required} = \frac{P_{heater} \times 1.25}{V}$$

For 3,000W heater on 240V: $I_{required} = 3,000 × 1.25 / 240 = 15.6$ amps Use 20A circuit with 12 AWG wire minimum

Voltage Options

• 120V: Small heaters <1,500 watts
• 208V: Multi-family buildings with 3-phase service
• 240V: Most residential applications, higher efficiency
• 277V: Commercial buildings (rarely residential)

Higher voltage reduces current for same power, allowing smaller conductors and lower voltage drop.

Control Strategies

Thermostat Types

Line Voltage Thermostats Direct switching of full load current:

• Rating: 22A typical (5,280W at 240V)
• Sensing element: Bimetal coil or electronic sensor
• Differential: 1-3°F (mechanical), 0.5-1°F (electronic)
• Location: Each room or zone
• Wiring: Series with heating element

Low Voltage Thermostats Control relay or contractor for element switching:

• Thermostat voltage: 24V (isolated from line)
• Contactor rating: Matches heater load
• Allows programmable and smart thermostats
• Better temperature control accuracy
• Higher installation cost

Zone Control

Individual Room Control Separate thermostat per space optimizes comfort and energy use:

• Bedrooms set back during day
• Common areas set back at night
• Unoccupied spaces at minimum temperature
• Energy savings: 10-20% compared to single zone

Programmable Setback Automatic temperature reduction during unoccupied periods:

$$E_{saved} = P_{heat} \times t_{setback} \times \frac{\Delta T_{setback}}{T_i - T_o}$$

Where:

• $E_{saved}$ = energy saved (kWh)
• $P_{heat}$ = heating power (kW)
• $t_{setback}$ = setback duration (hours)
• $\Delta T_{setback}$ = setback temperature reduction (°F)
• $T_i - T_o$ = design temperature difference (°F)

8-hour nighttime setback from 70°F to 62°F (10% reduction in design load): Typical savings 8-12% of heating energy

Smart Controls

Occupancy-Based Operation Motion or infrared sensors activate heating when space occupied:

• Instant heat for bathrooms, utility rooms
• Eliminates heating unoccupied spaces
• Compatible with fast-response radiant panels or fan-forced units
• Not suitable for slow-response systems (thermal mass lag)

Demand Response Integration Utility-controlled load shedding during peak demand:

• Temporary setback (2-4°F) during peak periods
• Reduces grid stress and may provide utility credits
• Requires communication protocol (WiFi, Zigbee, etc.)

Energy Efficiency and Operating Costs

Source Energy Considerations

Conversion Efficiency Chain

1. Generation: 33-60% (fuel to electricity at power plant)
2. Transmission: 92-94% (grid losses)
3. Distribution: 97-99% (local distribution)
4. End Use: 100% (electric resistance heater)

Overall source energy efficiency: 30-40% for fossil fuel generation, higher for renewable sources.

Operating Cost Comparison

Annual Heating Cost For electric resistance heating:

$$C_{annual} = \frac{HDD \times 24 \times UA}{\eta_{equipment} \times 3,413} \times C_{electricity}$$

Where:

• $HDD$ = heating degree days (°F·days)
• $UA$ = building heat loss coefficient (BTU/hr·°F)
• $\eta_{equipment}$ = equipment efficiency (1.0 for resistance)
• $C_{electricity}$ = electricity cost ($/kWh)

For 1,500 ft² well-insulated home (25,000 BTU/hr design load) in 5,000 HDD climate at $0.12/kWh: $C_{annual} = (5,000 × 24 × 25,000) / (1.0 × 3,413) × 0.12 = $10,545$

Versus heat pump at 250% efficiency (COP 2.5): $4,218

Cost Reduction Strategies

Building Envelope Improvements Reduce heat loss before sizing electric heating:

• Air sealing: 10-20% load reduction
• Insulation upgrades: 15-30% load reduction
• Window improvements: 10-15% load reduction
• Combined impact: 30-50% total load reduction

Time-of-Use Optimization If utility offers TOU rates:

• Thermal mass storage during off-peak hours
• Setback during peak price periods
• Programmable control for automatic optimization

Hybrid Heating Systems Combine electric resistance with heat pump:

• Heat pump for mild weather (>35-40°F outdoor)
• Electric backup for extreme cold
• Optimizes operating cost and equipment sizing

Safety Requirements

Electrical Safety

Overcurrent Protection

• Dedicated circuit per heater or heater group
• Breaker sized 125% of continuous load minimum
• GFCI protection for bathroom applications
• Arc-fault protection per NEC 2020+ requirements

Grounding and Bonding

• Metal enclosures must be grounded
• Equipment grounding conductor in all circuits
• Bonding of metal junction boxes
• Listed and labeled equipment only

Fire Safety

Clearances to Combustibles

• Baseboard: 1 inch minimum below drapes/curtains
• Wall heaters: 6-12 inches clearance to furniture
• Radiant panels: Per manufacturer listing (typically 3-6 inches from ceiling for ceiling-mount)
• Never cover or obstruct heaters (fire hazard)

Thermal Limits Built-in safety controls required:

• High-limit thermostat: Opens at 120-140°F (baseboard)
• Overheat protection: 180-200°F maximum (enclosed units)
• Automatic reset after cooling
• Manual reset for certain fault conditions

Installation Requirements

NEC Article 424 Fixed electric space heating equipment requirements:

• Branch circuit sizing (125% rule)
• Disconnecting means within sight
• Control and protective devices
• Clearances and mounting specifications
• Receptacle restrictions near baseboard heaters

Local Codes Verify jurisdiction-specific requirements:

• Dedicated circuits for each room
• Specific clearance dimensions
• Thermostat placement standards
• Labeling and documentation

Maintenance and Troubleshooting

Routine Maintenance

Cleaning

• Monthly: Vacuum dust from fins and grilles
• Quarterly: Wipe element and housing
• Annually: Inspect wiring connections for tightness
• Never spray water on energized equipment

Inspection Annual service checks:

• Thermostat calibration (±2°F acceptable)
• Element continuity test
• Current draw verification (should match rating ±5%)
• High-limit function test
• Fan operation (forced-air units)

Common Issues

Heater Not Operating

1. Verify power at breaker and disconn ect
2. Test thermostat with bypass (jumper terminals)
3. Check element continuity with multimeter
4. Inspect high-limit switch for trip condition
5. Verify proper voltage at heater terminals

Inadequate Heat Output

• Undersized for load (recalculate heat loss)
• Low voltage at heater (check circuit voltage drop)
• Failed elements (partial operation)
• Blocked airflow (dust accumulation, furniture obstruction)
• Incorrect thermostat location (sensing errors)

Frequent High-Limit Trips

• Blocked airflow
• Fan failure (forced-air units)
• Excessive element temperature (improper voltage)
• Faulty high-limit control

Electrical Noise or Odor

• Arcing at connections (tighten or replace)
• Dust burning on elements (clean)
• Failed element sheath (replace element)
• Insulation breakdown (replace unit)

Electric resistance heating provides simple, reliable space heating when properly sized, installed, and maintained. Cost-effectiveness depends on local electricity rates, building envelope performance, and climate conditions.

Sections